Then maybe make that comment in your own mind as opposed to including her in your fantasy baseball game? I'm teasing you. However, comments like that, while well-intentioned, can make you come off sounding and looking lame AF. If she's that beautiful, she probably isn't surprised and could perhaps become more of a smug beyotch as a result. Or, as I said, she could be mildly annoyed. I tend to think that compliments, when rendered respectfully, should be welcome because there will come a day when they will stop. Ery'body gets old. I used to visit my grandmother, long-deceased, with my stepdad. He would walk in the convalescent home and tell all the women how beautiful they were and made each of them feel as if he'd come just to see them. He would bring ice cream and lavish them with attention and compliments. The looks on their faces were priceless....I guarantee a compliment rendered in that situation would be appreciated far more.