I wouldn't say it's the same situation. We more than likely have Randle coming in, so that softens the blow. Not to mention, our class is already sitting at #1. Bama was counting on the likes of Massie and some others to boost their class. Benton was a minor surprise and disappointment, but Massis is a HUGE shock and let down for the gumps.
...and Notre Dame continues to live off of their name cause they sure as hell haven't done anything, in recent history, that is promising for the future.