1. This is where I would have to elevate Manning if I were making a list. Unitas came from the days where QBs called their own plays, and the only time the coach had a say was during TOs and halftime. Manning comes the closest any QB has come to having that control since the mid 70's.
  2. Marino is the toughest to place, only because of the lack of a Super Bowl ring.

    That's sad for him. Had he won it just once, everybody would have him in the top 3 of all time.
  3. He's behind a few others as well.

    Favre, Unitas, Marino.

    Manning is nowhere near the best QB of all-time.

  4. :rolleye33::rolleye33::rolleye33::insane::insane::insane::dis::dis::dis:


    that dude michael jordan wasnt all that either.....
  5. Say what you want, but Aaron Brooks is in my top ten
    -Jim Haslett
  6. Perhaps I was not being serious.
  7. Wow. You have him, what, 15th best of all time?
  8. Not that low fool! Maybe 14th! :lol:

    No higher than 7th.
  9. It has taken me years to come to this conclusion, but I would rank them:
    The Jordan-like Suspension period may come to a close soon.
    1. Montana
    2. Marino
    3. Elway
    4. Unitas
    5. Mauck
    6. Brady
    7. Tarkenton
  10. Welcome to the board.

    Pretty funny, btw.