Of course we all have that right but we also have the right to bitch about the bitchers. I would be the last one here to try to restrict someone's opinions we have enough of that with the democrats.
One of my best friends is a huge Tide fan and he flat told me today that they don't deserve to go to the playoffs. He said exactly what you said about being 8-4. He also pointed out his displeasure in how Auburn ran the ball so well when Alabama knew that's all they had to stop because Auburn has no passing game and still couldn't stop them.
When you're talking "They could have lost", it's the wrong direction to go. Reality is they didn't lose & are currently ranked #6 with a 10-2 record.
I think calling posters not real fans and all that for voicing displeasure in getting curb stomped by a 4-7 is convincingly more than "bitching at the bitchers".