You get to pick 1 QB 2 RB 2WR and 1 TE QB- Montana RB- Earl Campbell RB- Gayle Sayers WR- Rice WR - Moss TE - Gonzales Who you got?
Can't argue with any of those except I would go with Tom Brady. I might put OJ Simpson in place of Sayers. Sayers career was cut short while the Juice had a long one.
Staubach was quite a bit more mobile than Brady. I'll give you losing the Super Bowls but that was against one of the greatest teams ever, especially defensively so can't really knock him for that. I probably wouldn't have picked Roger the Dodger but I can see it. As for the Carter pick, again, the theme was "Pick your team" not pick Bengals team. Let them man make his picks.
Any all time greatest list is going to cause disgreements. I could see if somebody made a case for Dan Marino even though he never won a SB. Or Emmitt Smith even though he ran behind maybe the greatest OL ever.
Wait is this for real life or is this fantasy? caught in a landslide in fantasy Montana wouldn’t register.