My complaint about the Sugar Bowl DVD is that it doesn't contain all of the pregame and postgame commentary--which my Tivo'd copy of the Sugar Bowl does. But I'm not sure how long my husband's going to care for my taking up 4 hours of our Tivo with the Sugar Bowl that we have on DVD.
It's the exact same quality as the tv broadcast was. Some points are "grainy" but thats just what televising a football game in the Superdome gets ya sometimes, bad camera work. What I mean is the film never comes out quite as crisp as it does under natural lighting.