I'm doing something right. I don't buy natural peanut butter. I never have but I have tried it when some hippy dippy friend said that was all he had
oooooooooo.....I see now. yes some natural stuff gets all dried out over time but some stay nice and creamy.
This thread reminded me how long it's been since I had a PB&J sandwich. So this afternoon I prepared a creamy PB and Welch's Grape jelly sandwich with a cold glass of milk. Damn, it was good.