No one is saying the earth does not go through cycles of warming and cooling. It is well known and documented. Think ice age, I know you know about that. Surely. I will pass on your questions, not that into it. Having said that . . . The issue, which is documented, in many ways, is the increase in the rate of warming, which has been correlated to the burning of carbon. I know you don’t believe the data, I have posted them in the past. I pledge I will try really hard to not comment on your future posts regarding climate change. We will disagree until either Hell freezes over or until humans manage to extinct themselves. My interest in the subject is not sufficient as to do stuff to upset you. Geaux Tigers!