Yeah I am thinking of another time where Andersen tried another 59 or 60 yarder to actually win a game against the Bears (I think) and it went wide right by just 2 feet, but was long by some 5-6 yards easily. I think the game I was thinking of when he hit the 60 yarder was against the Bears just before the half, in which the Saints were 7-0 going into the game and we had held the Bears to less than 100 yards offense until the last drive, in which the Bears scored a TD and won the game.
I think shoes with a flat front like that were declared illegal by the NFL a few years after the record.