I'm certainly not a Brady fan; but you gotta give the guy GOAT props at this point. The Patriots stuff was impressive enough. But then to go to TB and do it again. That's a damn strong QB.
I'm old enough to have watched Johnny U play. I wouldn't have him ranked in my top 5. Brady by far is #1 followed closely by Montana. #3 - #5 would be a toss up between Manning, Favre, & Elway.
era..... you can't rank all time as it's apples to pineapples. the league has undergone tremendous innovation and change over time....
My rankings are my opinion. Obviously you don't agree. Why do you think Unitas was the GOAT? Do you think he could play today?
in most sports, and even non sports like chess, the best to ever do it is playing now. tiger woods lebron rodgers mike trout magnus carlson federer the notable exception is hockey where gretzky was far better than any modern player. most eveyrone else from the past was shit compared to modern players. weaker, slower, stupider