not really. warren moon was the best but he beat his wife. doug williams was illiterate so i never liked him.
Wasn't Honey Badger about 5th in the Heisman? If you want to take away Heismans due to how they fared in the NFL, there would only be a handful of Heisman winners ever. RG3's rookie season proved he has talent. NFL defenses are so much faster, bigger, and sophisticated than in college that it takes a special mindset to last at QB for 10+ years. It's that fine line of confident while being truly humble. I wouldn't give up completely on RG3 although could also see him regressing further. Some think that the Texans could be a spot for him next year but I don't know if O'Brien would want him.
Can anybody say Eric Crouch? or Charlie Ward? Matt Leinart? Chris Winkie Dinkie Weinke? Rashaan Salaam? Or the Slinging Christian Tim Tebow?
Tebow deserved it as the best college player that year. Dude could run and throw jump passes as well as long fades which work better in the NCAA.