I think it is a mistake to make any coaching decisions based on recruiting. If they are great recruiters, but stink as coaches, they hurt the team in the long run. I know a lot of people put a lot of stock in recuiting, and it is important. But coaching the players well when they get here is a lot more important. Look what being a great recruiter did for Orgeron's success at GTHOM. GEAUX TIGERS
Absolutely. The only criteria in deciding whether or not to retain a coach should be based solely on his success as a coach.