Said it before and I'll say it again, I'd go after Herman 1st. He is hungry, has something to prove. Fisher is chasing ghost and dollar signs and his life won't be affected regardless of what happens from here on out. He is almost Les Miles already and he isn't even here yet.
I m trying to find a way to play devil's advocate with your post but can't find anything you said that far fetched
O > Pellini? I'm thinking Pellini > O, except O is a bad-ass recruiter. Maybe worth taking a shot on O at DC if he isn't gone HCing somewhere. Just not sure we'd get the Xs & Os that Pellini could bring. But if we get a repeat of Chief's recruiting, don't matter how firm the DC's smarts is.
O at HC makes me feel like a case of bubbly guts might be rearing its ugly head, but I do really like the guy. I'd think real hard about the DC position, he could be picked up elsewhere if we don't move him up. I wonder if the Syracuse thing was an effort to impose that on our subconscious? Ole Miss HC is an ugly blemish on considering him any higher than an assistant.
I don't think anyone is seriously talking about O as HC. the conversation was about the DC position between O, Pellini and Muschump.
I suggested Pelini for DC last weekend and was lambasted for it. He's still my #1 pick. I want to see some fire in the locker room. Plus, I think he and Coach O would get along very well.