China and human rights violations? Big deal! We profile Mexicans.

A better way to put that is "before they had a chance to amend it".

See Post #4.

 

That's not what happened. There was no discussion of human rights violations going on at the time the asst sec'y of state brought up the Arizona law.

And you cannot have this discussion without pointing out that the Arizona Law does not violate any human, mexican or any others' rights.

 

The law doesn't, but police armed with this law will be able to tip toe around people's civil rights. But they do that with every other law too, so nevermind.

 

I was about to jump all over you. :hihi:

 

So........whether I read it or not means I don't understand? Actually it means it doesn't matter if I read it or not. Maybe you don't understand.

 

i will give you that point even tho i think the other side is completely off base, which is why i think even making a correlation on the debate of such is off target.

the point i am trying to get across, which seems to be not happening, is that, IMO, to even suggest that the arizona law is violating human rights, which the critics suggest, is implying that the charge it is on par with china's human rights violations has credibility.

yes, it has and i dont question that. i am talking about those that disagree with the arizona law. quite frankly, i dont hear the same type uproar over the federal laws which are the same. i know that many in the mexican american community have had a problem with the federal laws, because god forbid we not just open the borders to them. but the overwhelming majority of those that disagree with the arizona law are completely mum about the federal law. i bring that up because if the arizona law is a rights violation, those same people (or the majority of them) that are making this a debate havent cared that the same law has been at the federal level. what i am getting at, is that makes a large part of the debate from the other side hypocritical.

i dont spin right and i dont spin left. i know obama isnt to blame for everything. however, when i disagree with things his administration does, i will say so. and i think their entire response to the arizona law has been a knee jerk reaction.

the obama administration could have said we have national debates on issues and laws ranging from the economy to human rights and we allow free discussion of such. to bring the arizona law into it, does nothing but add legitimacy to the false charges by its opponents that it violates human rights.