I don't count games in which the starters were pulled or the QB did not play the entire game Brees/Payton 47-12 Manning 48-12 Brady 49-12 That includes 2 games in which Drew Brees drove the Saints to a potential game winning FG inside of a 40 yarder only to have it missed and lose in OT. Brees is the only one to win a Super Bowl during this time period.