Well duh. IN playing an entire season, you have all games to judge. None of you, and I mean this, none of you can give any objective data on why FSU is an actually better team. But fuck it. Concede the SEC is not as good as the ACC. Is this what you want?
Let me say this again. Bama HAS THE MOST CURRENT RANKED WINS OF ANY TEAM IN THE TOP 5.... IN both arguments, Bama is better.
I dont know. Maybe the committee ate tacos the night before.... I am going to ask you directly. What matters more. Record or who you played?
you want OBJECTIVE? I can do that. the ACC has a winning record against the SEC this year (including Florida State being 2-0 against them). So what makes the SEC better? not games played, which is "objective". has to be popular opinion, which is "subjective" people point out that FSU looked less than spectacular with their backup QB. I point out that only 1 week ago Alabama needed a miracle fluke to beat a very average (at best) Auburn team. And that was WITH all of their starters. FSU and Alabama have 1 common opponent this year. LSU and Florida State's win over them was more dominating than Alabama's was. oh wait, the games that did happen aren't what really matters. it's what we "feel will happen" that should count.
we can skip right over this bullshit. I'm going to say winning and you're going to post the ridiculous Liberty argument. so I'll ask you, if Schedule Strength is most important why is Michigan #1? if it's because they are unbeaten, then why is Florida State not in the top 3? if it's who we think would win, why are UGA and tOSU not in?
