I think you did the same thing I almost did....thought there was only one list. There's a AL and a NL; Wagner, Schmidt and Bench were all NL selections.
Not familiar with Eddie Collins, but he must have been something to get the AL 2B spot over Rod Carew.
his ‘99 & ‘00 seasons were just ridiculous 41-10 ; 1.90 era ; 597 k ; 69 bb made the entire league look foolish