Guilbeau sticks it to the ignorant: | Page 9 | TigerFan.com

upsizin · Feb 13, 2006

max said:

I hope this was a joke post. Guilbeau knows nothing about football. I remember talking to him before the national championship season about how I was excited that we would have a healthy Mauck back and he told me that Mauck would never start over Marcus Randall. To quote Guilbeau as an authority on football is truly stupid. Because a newspaper hired him as a journalist does not mean he knows any more about football than anyone on this site. And another thing...The jury is still out on the quarterback, but I would guess that Flynn should have the inside track. He manages the offense better, throws a more catchable pass, and runs better. I like Russell. He has a great arm, but I would rather have Flynn quarterbacking my team. At least based on what I have seen in the games. And before people say you can't tell by looking at the games. That is what scouts look at and they do a pretty good job of analyzing talent.
Click to expand...

FOR THE WIN

max · Feb 13, 2006

I think this is the first post that I've ever read of yours that wasn't a link to your site. Good job!
Click to expand...

What? I don't have a site. I think you have me confused with someone else.

upsizin · Feb 13, 2006

hey guys remember that time I hijacked mac's username and posted all those gay porn sites???

SabanFan · Feb 13, 2006

Ch0sn0ne said:

I think this is the first post that I've ever read of yours that wasn't a link to your site. Good job!
Click to expand...

That's MRX

LSUthrowsheat · Feb 13, 2006

CParso said:

Just as a side bit, then JaMarcus gets credit for taking us to the SECCG, and for for only having three losses to his name as a starter for LSU.

A team's results & successes do not mean that the QB is great. It's simple.
Click to expand...

This statement about a TEAMS success is ridiculous! A teams results and successes have EVERYTHING to do with how he is remembered! Timmy Chang had one of the best college careers of anyone elses in college football....no championships,hell not even a conference champion! NO ONE WILL REMEMBER TIMMY CHANG, therefore not a great QB! How many people remember Tommy Frazier? Not many even though he led Nebraska to MANY WINS! AND as a side bit Jamarcus will get credit for leading his LSU fighting tigers to the sec championship! And I hope CParso you don't judge how good a qb is by his ability off of the field....as in a 40 yard dash time or how high he can jump!
"A team's results & successes do not mean that the QB is great. It's simple" Nice Quote!

mpadow · Feb 13, 2006

CParso said:

Just as a side bit, then JaMarcus gets credit for taking us to the SECCG, and for for only having three losses to his name as a starter for LSU.

A team's results & successes do not mean that the QB is great. It's simple.
Click to expand...

Those three losses are three times as many losses Mauck had. Russell also lost 2 other games in which he played a substantial amount, bringing that loss total to 5, Randle also bailed him out of the Florida game last year.

tin4 · Feb 13, 2006

CParso said:

"Apparently what I'm trying to say isn't coming through. Ability creates results. A great QB will get results, but just because a QB gets results, doesn't mean that the QB is great."

And it obviously still isnt coming through.

What the hell does that mean. That made no sense at all. Let me try to understand this:

Great QB equals results
Great Results not equal to Great QB
So a quaterback that just gets results is great, but one that gets great results is not great.
Is that right?

And antother thing...If you play college football/quarterback, especially in the SEC, there is no question to whether or not you have the ability. Its how you use that ability combined with your knowledge of the game/intelligence that makes you successful.
Click to expand...

downtown · Feb 13, 2006

Someone mentioned Tommy Frazier for Nebraska...That dude was one of the most awesome players I've ever seen (in any sport). That 75-yard td run he had in the National Championship game in 1996 was possibly the most awesome individual run I've ever seen. I think that was the best team I've ever seen in my life as well. They absolutely killed a beyond-awesome Florida team. I'll never forget that. I can't speak for anyone else, but I remember him clearly.

I remember Timmy Chang too and I can recall the Hawaii fans booing him like crazy in Hawaii one game. So you see, even in paradise people boo players. Who would have thunk it? But yeah, I think you're right, nobody will really remember him because he put up stats that didn't mean much without championships, etc.

Ch0sn0ne · Feb 13, 2006

max said:

What? I don't have a site. I think you have me confused with someone else.
Click to expand...

LOL, sorry bro. had you confused with mrx. Got off work early today and had some drinks. A's and R's started looking the same.

Tiger1958 · Feb 14, 2006

downtown said:

Someone mentioned Tommy Frazier for Nebraska...That dude was one of the most awesome players I've ever seen (in any sport). That 75-yard td run he had in the National Championship game in 1996 was possibly the most awesome individual run I've ever seen. I think that was the best team I've ever seen in my life as well. They absolutely killed a beyond-awesome Florida team. I'll never forget that. I can't speak for anyone else, but I remember him clearly.

I remember Timmy Chang too and I can recall the Hawaii fans booing him like crazy in Hawaii one game. So you see, even in paradise people boo players. Who would have thunk it? But yeah, I think you're right, nobody will really remember him because he put up stats that didn't mean much without championships, etc.
Click to expand...

_ Tommy Frazier is a running back who played QB.

_ If LSU QBs passed as much as Timmy Chang we would have the same result.

_ Go back & look at BYU when N. Chow was the assitant there. I'm sure ppl remember them as some of the best of the best QBs in college football. They never won a real NC during that time.