best version of a great great song

Almost, the live at Pompeii version is better!

david is so great

I will give you this much @GiantDuckFan , when God wants to hear a guitar he asks Gilmour to play it!

god knows a good thing when she/he hears it

is Clapton transitioning?

Gilmour > Clapton

agreed.
was a play on the pics from back in day of the graffiti.

So Eric Clapton, a session guitarist, the only non-Beatle guitarist to play on a Beatles album. While my Guitar Gently Weeps", both solo & rhythm with George Harrison. The guitarist for Cream. "White Room & Sushine of your Love" - Cream, the guy who wrote & played & sang Layla, along with Duane Allman on slide guitar, is not as good as "Emphasis guitarist" David Gilmour? "You can really feel that note, Bro." - Floyd fan boys.

I'd give Gilmour a shot as possibly a better song writer, but better guitarist? No.

I'd take Gilmour above Clapton too.

but when you get that high on the list, it's almost like arguing who is the sexiest Swedish Bikini Model.
there are no wrong answers